Score: 3

"needs a lot of improvement"

submission: 101 things to do Part.1

date: 16 hours ago

I thought the animation style in this was way too simple. I thought that sticking to sticks and simply drawn backgrounds was a bad idea. The concept of the animation was just fine. But the way you brought it together was just poor. If you took more than a day and put more effort into trying to make this better it would be much more successful. But if you are simply doing this only for fun and don't expect praise for it and know yourself that it is bad that is just fine. But don't expect a good response.

Score: 4

"Needs work"

submission: Milano Toons 011

date: November 22, 2009

Each part was pretty simple. The parts by fat badger and arse on toast were both pretty plain. Not just because they were loops. But also because they had pretty bad animation and made no sense. The part by mushroom boy wasn't too good either. I couldn't really understand what it was about. But at least the animation and voices in it were okay. So this wasn't a great collab. But not at all unwatchable.

Score: 2

"Nothing great"

submission: Meet Pico Clock!

date: November 22, 2009

It was actually kind of irritating. I wish that you used subtitles in this so that we could understand the characters better. Also I could enjoy this a lot more if you threw in at least some frame by frame animation. Also some music during the movie wouldn't hurt. As well as improved backgrounds. I found this kind of dull and not very funny. I understand that it is your first but it is a bad start. You should have at least tried to do some frame by frame. But you didn't and well. This turned out badly.

Score: 8

"Pretty good tune"

submission: Giga La Nora

date: October 31, 2009

Had a good cheerful feeling to it. I liked the clarinet a lot. Yet at certain times it seemed to go a bit off key. Plus it got a bit redundant how it was basically the same thing over and over again. Also although I know it is only 45 seconds it felt like at least two minutes. Which is very strange. I have never heard a song do this before. Also great intro and outro. They came in quick and did their jobs well.

Score: 9

"Could be in some sort of scary movie"

submission: Ominous Theme

date: October 19, 2009

I liked how long the note holds from the begining and how over time you threw in some other scary sounds and effects to help build up the suspenseful feeling. But man I would have totally enjoyed this if you just put in something big at the end to end all of the suspenseful feeling. Because I just don't like how it just goes on forever. That and the ending is bad.

Score: 9

"Excellent"

submission: [S:C] Avoider 2.0

date: October 14, 2009

I love this type of catchy Techno music that sounds great and isn't too repetitive. But man it's a shame you decided to make it so short. I was really starting to enjoy it and then it cut off. It was a big letdown that you did this. Because I'm seeing a lot of great songs nowadays that sound pretty wonderful but for no reason at all are cut off way too short into the song.

I thought that if you made this a more comfortable length I would have just loved it. Because the tune is already fantastic. So why did you cut it off though?