Score: 5

"Alright then...."

submission: The Disney Collab

date: November 6, 2009

Thia wasn't at all a bad idea for a collaboration. But it didn't turn out to be very good because it lacked decent humor in every single part. Some parts were very badly animated most were nicely designed though.

The intro wasn't a bad beggining to this in gave a good idea of what the collab was going to be like. Plus it referenced a lot of disney franchises. The menu wasn't bad either. It had a pretty nice way to choose which part we wanted to watch. But the Mickey Mouse Voice in the background got extremely annoying and was just a poor attempt at humor. I also would wish that when we hit play all it would let us go back in forth between parts.

Ben Ninechecker's part had very good animation to it and fantastic voice acting as well. But rather dull humor to it. It had a few strange twists in it that I enjoyed but nothing that actually made me laugh. The music fit the unusual theme pretty well. Even though it does not fit the Winnie the Pooh theme very well.

Tard Fard's part was the least enjoyable of the whole collaboration just because the animation was so crude and lacked so much detail in it. I can see that it was trying to make a point about how bad of an intro Fantasia has and how misleading the the box is. But I could not find any entertainment in it.

Vylent's part was definetly the best in terms of animation. He did a very good remake of the animation in steamboat Willie so it looked spectacular. And despite the great animation in that part it was still a dissapointment that it ended so quickly on such a lame joke. I wish you would have at least extended the animation before doing that.

Hulaloo's part was obsenely random. And in quite an unexpected way. He completely changed around The Bambi movie plot in such a twisted and violent way. But not in a funny way. The animation was okay.

Boneofchicken's, Emanhatten's and Comick's parts were all pretty much the same. Just really short clips with no plot and pretty uniteresting childish humor. The animation in each of them were fine but the movies themselves just were not good.

The only part I really had laughs from would be Jonimator's second part with the spinach salad. It was a big suprise that I did not see coming. Although much like other part's it was not animated very well.

Score: 0

"Doesn't belong on newgrounds"

submission: Sonic says "shit"

date: November 6, 2009

As interesting as a video clip this was I did not like it one bit because It was so uncreative.All you did was grab a clip from the japanese sonic X and throw it into flash. This does not require any effort or talent making this flash very unenjoyable. If at least animated the sound clip that would have been a great way to still keep this submission's concept while having at least something good in it. But since you didn't this lacked tons of quality. If the only reason that you uploaded this was because someone requested it you should have just uploaded it to youtube. Because things like these do not belong on Newgrounds. They have nothing pleasing in them.

Score: 10

"Entertaining"

submission: The Gas Station

date: November 5, 2009

I enjoy how you like to mix it up in your cartoons and do things that are not done by most animators.

Score: 8

"Pretty good tune"

submission: Giga La Nora

date: October 31, 2009

Had a good cheerful feeling to it. I liked the clarinet a lot. Yet at certain times it seemed to go a bit off key. Plus it got a bit redundant how it was basically the same thing over and over again. Also although I know it is only 45 seconds it felt like at least two minutes. Which is very strange. I have never heard a song do this before. Also great intro and outro. They came in quick and did their jobs well.

Score: 9

"Could be in some sort of scary movie"

submission: Ominous Theme

date: October 19, 2009

I liked how long the note holds from the begining and how over time you threw in some other scary sounds and effects to help build up the suspenseful feeling. But man I would have totally enjoyed this if you just put in something big at the end to end all of the suspenseful feeling. Because I just don't like how it just goes on forever. That and the ending is bad.

Score: 9

"Excellent"

submission: [S:C] Avoider 2.0

date: October 14, 2009

I love this type of catchy Techno music that sounds great and isn't too repetitive. But man it's a shame you decided to make it so short. I was really starting to enjoy it and then it cut off. It was a big letdown that you did this. Because I'm seeing a lot of great songs nowadays that sound pretty wonderful but for no reason at all are cut off way too short into the song.

I thought that if you made this a more comfortable length I would have just loved it. Because the tune is already fantastic. So why did you cut it off though?